Bruce Springsteen Forum

Ich hab das Seeger - Album weggelassen, weil es halt nicht seine eigenen Songs sind !

Und Tracks hab ich weggelassen, weil es ja kein Studioalbum im eigentlichen Sinne ist, wie ich meine .

Aber es steht jedem frei, auch diese Alben zu bewerten.

Bin dann auch gerne bereit, für diese eine Durchschnittsbewertung durchzuführen.

...

Stimme Dir zu.

Hmmmmmmmmmmmhhhhhhh ?????????

Was wollt ihr beiden mir jetzt damit sagen ???????

Ich wollte auch nur auf meine berühmte zurückhaltende Art meine Verwunderung über Darkness666' Beitrag zum Ausdruck bringen.
Vielleicht hat er irgendwas hingeschrieben, gemerkt, dass es Unsinn war, und es kurzerhand gelöscht, weiß aber womöglich nicht, dass man den letzten Beitrag eines Threads als Verfasser löschen kann.

Hab' heute mal zwecks Benotung The River, Lucky Town, Human Touch und Devils & Dust durchgehört.
Auf The River ist außer den vielen Granaten doch auch der eine oder andere Rohrkrepierer dabei, der den Notendurchschnitt etwas nach unten treibt (I Wanna Marry You, Ramrod, I'm A Rocker).
Lucky Town wird womöglich einen etwas besseren Schnitt kriegen als ich erwartet hätte.

Meine Auflistung kommt demnächst.

Letzten Thread löschen ist mir tatsächlich entfallen gewesen ...
Ansonsten muss ich meine Benotung für WOAD + TGOTJ doch noch einmal überdenken - wozu ich mich aber erst nach drücken des Absenden-Buttons entschloss ...

...wohl eher WOAD ein zweites Mal hören .....TOGOTJ noch mal überdenken ? Was gibt es bei diesem Meisterwerk groß zu überdenken ? Nimm ansonsten meine Benotung, das kommt dann hin

Nix, aber ich werd' das Album heute auch noch einmal hören, um meine Bewertung zu finalisieren.

So, wobei ich sagen muss, dass die Song-für-Song-Bewertung das Ganze etwas verzerrt. TGOTJ zum Beispiel funktioniert als Album viel besser, als es die Einzelbewertung erwarten lassen würde.

Born in the USA / Born in the USA / 4
Born in the USA / Cover Me / 3
Born in the USA / Darlington County / 1
Born in the USA / Working on the Highway / 2
Born in the USA / Downbound Train / 1
Born in the USA / I'm on Fire / 1
Born in the USA / No Surrender / 2
Born in the USA / Bobby Jean /1
Born in the USA / I'm Goin' Down / 2
Born in the USA / Glory Days / 2
Born in the USA / Dancing in the Dark / 2
Born in the USA / My Hometown / 2 / Gesamtnote / 1,92

Darkness on the Edge of Town / Badlands / 1
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Adam Raised a Cain / 1
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Something in the Night /2
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Candy's Room / 2
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Racing in the Street / 1
Darkness on the Edge of Town / The Promised Land / 2
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Factory / 3
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Streets of Fire / 3
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Prove it All Night / 3
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Darkness on the Edge of Town /2 Gesamtnote / 2,0

Born to Run / Thunder Road / 1
Born to Run / Tenth Avenue Freeze-out / 1
Born to Run / Night / 2
Born to Run / Backstreets / 1
Born to Run / Born to Run / 1
Born to Run / She's the One / 1
Born to Run / Meeting Across the River / 1
Born to Run / Jungleland / 1 Gesamtnote /1,12

Nebraska / Nebraska / 2
Nebraska / Atlantic City / 1
Nebraska / Mansion on the Hill / 2
Nebraska / Johnny 99 / 3
Nebraska / Highway Patrolman / 1
Nebraska / State Trooper / 3
Nebraska / Used Cars / 2
Nebraska / Open All Night / 2
Nebraska / My Father's House / 2
Nebraska / Reason to Believe / 1 Gesamtnote / 1,9


The River / The Ties that Bind 3
The River / Sherry Darling 2
The River / Jackson Cage 2
The River / Two Hearts 2
The River / Independence Day 1
The River / Hungry Heart 2
The River / Out in the Street 2
The River / Crush on You 3
The River / You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch) 1
The River / I Wanna Marry You 4
The River / The River 1
The River / Point Blank 2
The River / Cadillac Ranch 2
The River / I'm a Rocker 2
The River / Fade Away 2
The River / Stolen Car 2
The River / Ramrod 4
The River / The Price You Pay 3
The River / Drive All Night 2
The River / Wreck on the Highway 2 Gesamtnote / 2,1


Magic / Radio Nowhere 1
Magic / You'll Be Comin' Down 2
Magic / Livin' in the Future 3
Magic / Your Own Worst Enemy 3
Magic / Gypsy Biker 2
Magic / Girls in Their Summer Clothes 1
Magic / I'll Work for Your Love 2
Magic / Magic 3
Magic / Last to Die 1
Magic /Long Walk Home1
Magic / Devil's Arcade 3
Magic / Terry's Song 1 Gesamtnote / 1,92

The Rising / Lonesome Day 2
The Rising / Into the Fire 2
The Rising / Waitin' on a Sunny Day 1
The Rising / Nothing Man 2
The Rising / Countin' on a Miracle 3
The Rising / Empty Sky 3
The Rising / Worlds Apart3
The Rising / Let's Be Friends 4
The Rising / Further On (Up the Road) 2
The Rising / The Fuse 3
The Rising / Mary's Place 4
The Rising / You're Missing 2
The Rising / The Rising 3
The Rising / Paradise 4
The Rising / My City of Ruins 1 Gesamtnote / 2,6

Tunnel of Love / Ain't Got You 1
Tunnel of Love / Tougher Than the Rest 1
Tunnel of Love / All That Heaven Will Allow 2
Tunnel of Love / Spare Parts 2
Tunnel of Love / Cautious Man 2
Tunnel of Love / Walk Like a Man 2
Tunnel of Love / Tunnel of Love 2
Tunnel of Love / Two Faces 3
Tunnel of Love / Brilliant Disguise 1
Tunnel of Love / One Step Up 1
Tunnel of Love / When You're Alone 2
Tunnel of Love / Valentine's Day 2 Gesamtnote / 1,75

Working On a Dream / Outlaw Pete 3
Working On a Dream / My Lucky Day 2
Working On a Dream / Working On a Dream 3
Working On a Dream / Queen of the Supermarket 5
Working On a Dream / What Love Can Do 4
Working On a Dream / This Life 4
Working On a Dream / Good Eye 4
Working On a Dream / Tomorrow Never Knows 4
Working On a Dream / Life Itself 4
Working On a Dream / Kingdom of Days 4
Working On a Dream / Surprise, Surprise 5
Working On a Dream / The Last Carnival 2
Working On a Dream / The Wrestler 2 Gesamtnote / 3,54

Devils & Dust / Devils & Dust 1
Devils & Dust / All The Way Home 2
Devils & Dust / Reno 2
Devils & Dust / Long Time Comin' 1
Devils & Dust / Black Cowboys 2
Devils & Dust / Maria's Bed 3
Devils & Dust / Silver Palomino 3
Devils & Dust / Jesus Was an Only Son 2
Devils & Dust / Leah 2
Devils & Dust / The Hitter 2
Devils & Dust / All I'm Thinkin' About 2
Devils & Dust / Matamoras Banks 2 Gesamtnote / 2,0

Lucky Town / Better Days 2
Lucky Town / Lucky Town 2
Lucky Town / Local Hero 3
Lucky Town / If I Should Fall Behind 2
Lucky Town / Leap of Faith 2
Lucky Town / The Big Muddy 2
Lucky Town / Living Proof 3
Lucky Town / Book of Dreams 2
Lucky Town / Souls of the Departed 1
Lucky Town / My Beautiful Reward 3 Gesamtnote / 2,3

Human Touch / Human Touch 2
Human Touch / Soul Driver 4
Human Touch / 57 Channels (and nothin' on) 2
Human Touch / Cross My Heart 4
Human Touch / Gloria's Eyes 4
Human Touch / With Every Wish 5
Human Touch / Roll of the Dice 3
Human Touch / Real World 3
Human Touch / All or Nothin' at All 3
Human Touch / Man's Job 4
Human Touch / I Wish I Were Blind 3
Human Touch / The Long Goodbye 3
Human Touch / Real Man 3
Human Touch / Pony Boy 3 Gesamtnote / 3,28

The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle/ The E Street Shuffle 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / 4th of July, Asbury Park (Sandy) 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Kitty's Back 2
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Wild Billy's Circus Story 2
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Incident on 57th Street 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Rosalita (Come Out Tonight) 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / New York City Serenade 1 Gesamtnote / 1,29

The Ghost of Tom Joad / The Ghost of Tom Joad 1
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Straight Time 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Highway 29 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Youngstown 1
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Sinaloa Cowboys 2
The Ghost of Tom Joad / The Line 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Balboa Park 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Dry Lightning 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / The New Timer 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Across the Border 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Galveston Bay 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / My Best Was Never Good Enough 3 Gesamtnote/ 2,5

Greetings from Asbury Park/ Blinded By the Light 2
Greetings from Asbury Park / Growin' Up 1
Greetings from Asbury Park / Mary Queen Of Arkansas 3
Greetings from Asbury Park / Does This Bus Stop At 82nd Street? 2
Greetings from Asbury Park / Lost In The Flood 1
Greetings from Asbury Park / The Angel 2
Greetings from Asbury Park / For You 1
Greetings from Asbury Park / Spirit in the Night 2
Greetings from Asbury Park / It's Hard to be a Saint in the City 2 Gesamtnote / 1,78

Top aktuell...... ( nach 12 Benotungen )

BtR und Darkness

gleichauf an der Spitze mit Notendurchschnitt 1,78 !!!!!!!

So, dass wärs soweit von mir ... und ich weiss endlich auch, dass tatsächlich "Nebraska" mein Lieblingsalbum ist

Album / Titel / Note

Born in the USA / Born in the USA / 2
Born in the USA / Cover Me / 4
Born in the USA / Darlington County / 2
Born in the USA / Working on the Highway / 2
Born in the USA / Downbound Train / 1
Born in the USA / I'm on Fire / 2
Born in the USA / No Surrender / 1
Born in the USA / Bobby Jean / 1
Born in the USA / I'm Goin' Down / 3
Born in the USA / Glory Days / 1
Born in the USA / Dancing in the Dark / 4
Born in the USA / My Hometown / 1 /
Gesamtnote : 2,0

Darkness on the Edge of Town / Badlands / 1
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Adam Raised a Cain / 2
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Something in the Night / 1
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Candy's Room / 3
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Racing in the Street / 1
Darkness on the Edge of Town / The Promised Land / 2
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Factory / 3
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Streets of Fire / 3
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Prove it All Night / 2
Darkness on the Edge of Town / Darkness on the Edge of Town / 1
Gesamtnote : 1,9

Born to Run / Thunder Road / 1
Born to Run / Tenth Avenue Freeze-out / 4
Born to Run / Night / 2
Born to Run / Backstreets / 2
Born to Run / Born to Run / 1
Born to Run / She's the One / 3
Born to Run / Meeting Across the River / 3
Born to Run / Jungleland / 1
Gesamtnote : 2,13

Nebraska / Nebraska / 1
Nebraska / Atlantic City / 1
Nebraska / Mansion on the Hill / 2
Nebraska / Johnny 99 / 1
Nebraska / Highway Patrolman / 1
Nebraska / State Trooper / 3
Nebraska / Used Cars / 2
Nebraska / Open All Night / 3
Nebraska / My Father's House / 2
Nebraska / Reason to Believe / 2
Gesamtnote : 1,8


The River / The Ties that Bind 2
The River / Sherry Darling 4
The River / Jackson Cage 1
The River / Two Hearts 3
The River / Independence Day 1
The River / Hungry Heart 4
The River / Out in the Street 3
The River / Crush on You 3
The River / You Can Look (But You Better Not Touch) 3
The River / I Wanna Marry You 4
The River / The River 1
The River / Point Blank 1
The River / Cadillac Ranch 4
The River / I'm a Rocker 3
The River / Fade Away 2
The River / Stolen Car 2
The River / Ramrod 3
The River / The Price You Pay 2
The River / Drive All Night 1
The River / Wreck on the Highway 1
Gesamtnote : 2,55


Magic / Radio Nowhere 2
Magic / You'll Be Comin' Down 3
Magic / Livin' in the Future 4
Magic / Your Own Worst Enemy 6
Magic / Gypsy Biker 1
Magic / Girls in Their Summer Clothes 4
Magic / I'll Work for Your Love 4
Magic / Magic 2
Magic / Last to Die 1
Magic / Long Walk Home 1
Magic / Devil's Arcade 1
Magic / Terry's Song 2
Gesamtnote : 2,58

The Rising / Lonesome Day 3
The Rising / Into the Fire 2
The Rising / Waitin' on a Sunny Day 3
The Rising / Nothing Man 2
The Rising / Countin' on a Miracle 2
The Rising / Empty Sky 2
The Rising / Worlds Apart 5
The Rising / Let's Be Friends 6
The Rising / Further On (Up the Road) 2
The Rising / The Fuse 5
The Rising / Mary's Place 4
The Rising / You're Missing 3
The Rising / The Rising 2
The Rising / Paradise 2
The Rising / My City of Ruins 1
Gesamtnote : 2,93

Tunnel of Love / Ain't Got You 3
Tunnel of Love / Tougher Than the Rest 2
Tunnel of Love / All That Heaven Will Allow 3
Tunnel of Love / Spare Parts 4
Tunnel of Love / Cautious Man 3
Tunnel of Love / Walk Like a Man 3
Tunnel of Love / Tunnel of Love 4
Tunnel of Love / Two Faces 3
Tunnel of Love / Brilliant Disguise 2
Tunnel of Love / One Step Up 3
Tunnel of Love / When You're Alone 4
Tunnel of Love / Valentine's Day 3
Gesamtnote : 3,08

Working On a Dream / Outlaw Pete 2
Working On a Dream / My Lucky Day 3
Working On a Dream / Working On a Dream 6
Working On a Dream / Queen of the Supermarket 5
Working On a Dream / What Love Can Do 6
Working On a Dream / This Life 6
Working On a Dream / Good Eye 6
Working On a Dream / Tomorrow Never Knows 3
Working On a Dream / Life Itself 4
Working On a Dream / Kingdom of Days 5
Working On a Dream / Surprise, Surprise 6
Working On a Dream / The Last Carnival 3
Working On a Dream / The Wrestler 2
Gesamtnote : 4,31

Devils & Dust / Devils & Dust 2
Devils & Dust / All The Way Home 3
Devils & Dust / Reno 2
Devils & Dust / Long Time Comin' 1
Devils & Dust / Black Cowboys 3
Devils & Dust / Maria's Bed 5
Devils & Dust / Silver Palomino 3
Devils & Dust / Jesus Was an Only Son 3
Devils & Dust / Leah 3
Devils & Dust / The Hitter 2
Devils & Dust / All I'm Thinkin' About 6
Devils & Dust / Matamoras Banks 1
Gesamtnote : 3,0

Lucky Town / Better Days 2
Lucky Town / Lucky Town 2
Lucky Town / Local Hero 4
Lucky Town / If I Should Fall Behind 4
Lucky Town / Leap of Faith 3
Lucky Town / The Big Muddy 3
Lucky Town / Living Proof 3
Lucky Town / Book of Dreams 3
Lucky Town / Souls of the Departed 1
Lucky Town / My Beautiful Reward 2
Gesamtnote : 2,7

Human Touch / Human Touch 2
Human Touch / Soul Driver 3
Human Touch / 57 Channels (and nothin' on) 6
Human Touch / Cross My Heart 4
Human Touch / Gloria's Eyes 4
Human Touch / With Every Wish 4
Human Touch / Roll of the Dice 4
Human Touch / Real World 5
Human Touch / All or Nothin' at All 3
Human Touch / Man's Job 3
Human Touch / I Wish I Were Blind 3
Human Touch / The Long Goodbye 3
Human Touch / Real Man 4
Human Touch / Pony Boy 5
Gesamtnote : 3,78

The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle/ The E Street Shuffle 3
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / 4th of July, Asbury Park (Sandy) 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Kitty's Back 2
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Wild Billy's Circus Story 3
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Incident on 57th Street 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / Rosalita (Come Out Tonight) 1
The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle / New York City Serenade 2
Gesamtnote : 1,86

The Ghost of Tom Joad / The Ghost of Tom Joad 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Straight Time 4
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Highway 29 5
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Youngstown 2
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Sinaloa Cowboys 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / The Line 4
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Balboa Park 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Dry Lightning 5
The Ghost of Tom Joad / The New Timer 4
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Across the Border 3
The Ghost of Tom Joad / Galveston Bay 5
The Ghost of Tom Joad / My Best Was Never Good Enough 6
Gesamtnote : 3,92

Greetings from Asbury Park / Blinded By the Light 1
Greetings from Asbury Park / Growin' Up 1
Greetings from Asbury Park / Mary Queen Of Arkansas 4
Greetings from Asbury Park / Does This Bus Stop At 82nd Street? 3
Greetings from Asbury Park / Lost In The Flood 2
Greetings from Asbury Park / The Angel 4
Greetings from Asbury Park / For You 1
Greetings from Asbury Park / Spirit in the Night 2
Greetings from Asbury Park / It's Hard to be a Saint in the City 3
Gesamtnote : 2,33

Nur so mal zwischendurch ( damit das hier nicht einschläft )

Aktuell die Plätze 50 bis 60:

Growin' Up  / 2,08
Mansion on the Hill /   2,15
My Father's House / 2,15
The Price You Pay  2,15
New York City Serenade/ 2,15
Tenth Avenue Freeze-out /   2,23
One Step Up  / 2,23
Adam Raised a Cain /   2,23
Fade Away  / 2,23
Better Days  / 2,23
For You  / 2,23

Note 2 bedeutet ( nur noch mal zur Erinnerung) "herausragender Song !

Deshalb werde ich, sobald ich mein Ranking poste, selbst bestimmen, was welche Note bedeutet.

Herausragend für Note 2 ist insofern Unsinn, als es gar nicht herausragt - das tut nur die Note 1.
Bei einer Sechser-Abstufung wie bei Schulnoten ist ein "Sehr gut" für die Note 3 ebenfalls hanebüchen.

Außerdem glaube ich nicht, dass sich alle, die hier ihre Bewertung gepostet haben, nach Deiner Definition gerichtet haben.
Note 2 ist nun mal einfach nur als gut in den Köpfen verankert.

wenn nun die Definition der Bewertung mitten in der "Umfrage" geändert wird, dann könnte es ein ziemliches Durcheinander geben

Das mag sein.
Aber deshalb kann ich dennoch keine Note 2 als Herausragend und 3 als Sehr gut verteilen.
Für mich wird Note 5 auch nicht Geht so bedeuten, sondern Schlecht, und 6 nicht Nicht mein Ding, sondern Unterirdisch.

Ich lass' mich dann gern von toughers Durchschnittsberechnungen ausnehmen.